{ "slug": "dp_004-q03-codex", "dp": "dp_004", "files": 30, "qid": "q03", "family": "multi_hop", "prompt": "Cross-referencing the defense's discovery responses (discovery/discovery-responses-received.md) with the filed complaint (pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md) and the document-production log (discovery/document-production-log.md): (a) Who was the licensed electrician on the Park kitchen project and what New York license number did he hold? (b) What exact annotation appeared on his invoice regarding the sink-adjacent outlet? (c) What companion document did the production log indicate was NOT produced alongside that annotation?", "gold": "(a) Pavlos Stamatopoulos; NY license #EL-449821. (b) \"1 GFCI omitted per HO request \u2014 see attached note\". (c) The referenced attached note was not produced.", "agent": "codex", "fs": { "agent": "codex", "success": true, "steps": 1, "inputTokens": 310156, "outputTokens": 4211, "totalTokens": 314367, "cost": 3.8482, "durationMs": 70481, "answer": "(a) The licensed electrician was **Pavlos Stamatopoulos**, master electrician, NY license **#EL-449821**. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:138).\n\n(b) The exact invoice annotation was: **\u201c1 GFCI omitted per HO request \u2014 see attached note\u201d**. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:107).\n\n(c) The missing companion document was the **\u201cattached note\u201d** referenced by that annotation, apparently meant to document the claimed homeowner request to omit/substitute the sink-side GFCI. The responses state no such note was attached or produced, while the production log only records the two-page electrician invoice at KCB-000022\u2013000023. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:162) and [production log](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md:52).", "judgeReason": "covers all asked facts", "toolCalls": 12, "trajectory": [ { "step": 1, "inputTokens": 310156, "outputTokens": 4211, "text": "I\u2019ll trace the cited discovery, pleading, and production-log files, then check `agent_memory/` as instructed for any prior notes or extracted answer.\nThe cited materials are under `agent_memory/`. I\u2019m searching for the electrician, invoice annotation, and production status across those files before answering.\nThe key entries agree on the electrician and license number. I\u2019m doing one broader pass for the exact phrasing around the invoice annotation and the missing companion item so I don\u2019t flatten a document-specific detail.\n(a) The licensed electrician was **Pavlos Stamatopoulos**, master electrician, NY license **#EL-449821**. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:138).\n\n(b) The exact invoice annotation was: **\u201c1 GFCI omitted per HO request \u2014 see attached note\u201d**. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:107).\n\n(c) The missing companion document was the **\u201cattached note\u201d** referenced by that annotation, apparently meant to document the claimed homeowner request to omit/substitute the sink-side GFCI. The responses state no such note was attached or produced, while the production log only records the two-page electrician invoice at KCB-000022\u2013000023. See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:162) and [production log](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md:52).", "toolCalls": [ { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'find agent_memory -maxdepth 3 -type f -print'\"}", "outputPreview": "agent_memory/research/contractor-licensing-research.md\nagent_memory/research/ny-small-claims-procedure-research.md\nagent_memory/research/damages-calculation-research.md\nagent_memory/research/precedent-cases-memo.md\nagent_memory/memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md\nagent_memory/memory/profiles/carmen-ostrowski-attorney-profile.md\nagent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md\nagent_memory\u2026", "outputChars": 1662 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'rg --files'\"}", "outputPreview": "CLAUDE.md\nAGENTS.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/client/status-updates-park.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/client/pre-hearing-prep-park.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/client/intake-emails-park.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/opposing/ortega-initial-correspondence.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/opposing/ortega-discovery-correspondence.md\nagent_memory/correspondence/opposing/pre-counsel-karras-demand.\u2026", "outputChars": 1682 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"sed -n '1,240p' agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": "# DEFENDANT'S RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFF'S INFORMAL DISCOVERY \u2014 Park v. Karras Custom Builders LLC, Index SC-002847-26/KI\n\n```\n[REC'D 2026-03-12 15:08 RC] [Bates stamp lower-right]\n```\n\n*Renee snapped a phone photo of the Bates stamp on the first page for the production log; the photo is filed under `/discovery/intake-photos/2026-03-12-bates-stamp.jpg` and referen\u2026", "outputChars": 19283 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'rg -n \\\"electrician|license|licensed|sink|outlet|invoice|annotation|produced|not produced|companion\\\" agent_memory/discovery agent_memory/pleadings'\"}", "outputPreview": "agent_memory/pleadings/demand-letter-2026-02-19.md:32:On November 4, 2025, Mr. Park and Karras Custom Builders LLC executed a written home-improvement contract for the complete renovation of the kitchen at 1612 Argyle Road. The agreed total contract price was Twenty-Four Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($24,500), payable in three installments: a deposit of Eight Thousand Dollars ($8,000) at signing,\u2026", "outputChars": 43904 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"sed -n '1,260p' agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": "# DOCUMENT PRODUCTION LOG \u2014 Park v. Karras Custom Builders LLC, Matter OL-2026-0019\n\n> Maintained by R. Choudhury. Last updated 2026-03-19 17:00.\n> Date-stamp ink: purple Pilot G-2 (firm convention for paralegal-maintained logs).\n> Epigraph (Carmen's standing instruction for case files): *\"We are made to persist. That's how we find out who we are.\"* \u2014 Tobias Wolff.\n\n---\n\n## 0. Header / Custodial I\u2026", "outputChars": 19725 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"sed -n '1,240p' agent_memory/pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": "```\n+--------------------------------------------------+\n| F I L E D |\n| KINGS COUNTY CIVIL COURT |\n| SMALL CLAIMS PART |\n| 2026 FEB 26 AM 11:47 |\n| Clerk: R. Imhotep |\n+--------------------------------------------------+\n```\n\nCIVIL COURT OF THE C\u2026", "outputChars": 19951 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'rg -n \\\"GFCI omitted|attached note|Pavlos|Stamatopoulos|Stamato|GFCI receptacle|sink location|HO request|companion|not produced|NOT produced|absent|missing\\\" agent_memory'\"}", "outputPreview": "agent_memory/correspondence/client/status-updates-park.md:27:4. Replace the non-GFCI receptacle adjacent to the sink with a code-compliant GFCI; permit + inspection cost included.\nagent_memory/correspondence/client/pre-hearing-prep-park.md:154:- **Settlement posture** \u2014 remains theoretical at $7,000 counter (cross-ref: 09_settlement-offer-exchange.md). I am NOT initiating further negotiation absen\u2026", "outputChars": 18100 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'smfs grep \\\"companion document not produced with invoice annotation sink outlet GFCI\\\" agent_memory/discovery'\"}", "outputPreview": "Error: auth failed (401)\n", "outputChars": 25 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'smfs grep \\\"electrician invoice annotation GFCI omitted attached note not produced\\\" agent_memory'\"}", "outputPreview": "Error: auth failed (401)\n", "outputChars": 25 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"find . -path './agent_memory' -prune -o -type f -path '*discovery*' -print\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": "", "outputChars": 0 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'pwd && ls -la && find . -maxdepth 2 -type d -print'\"}", "outputPreview": "/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004\ntotal 16\ndrwxr-xr-x@ 5 prasanna staff 160 May 13 03:05 .\ndrwxr-xr-x@ 14 prasanna staff 448 May 13 03:05 ..\n-rw-r--r--@ 1 prasanna staff 141 May 13 03:05 AGENTS.md\n-rw-r--r--@ 1 prasanna staff 141 May 13 03:05 CLAUDE.md\ndrwxr-xr-x@ 9 prasanna staff 288 May 13 03:05 agent_memory\n.\n./agent_memor\u2026", "outputChars": 578 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '100,166p' && nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '45,56p' && nl -ba agent_memory/pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md | sed -n '76,96p'\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": " 100\t### Bucket 3 \u2014 Subcontractor / Supplier Records\n 101\t\n 102\t**Produced.**\n 103\t\n 104\t- **Crystallo Surfaces invoice** for the quartz countertop slab, showing **batch QS-2025-1182**, the date of fabrication (2025-12-09), the delivery date (2025-12-19), and the manufacturer's standard 1-year limited warranty terms (excluding \"stress fractures attributable to substrate movement\"). *Bate\u2026", "outputChars": 21008 } ] } ] }, "smfs": { "agent": "codex", "success": true, "steps": 1, "inputTokens": 211443, "outputTokens": 2759, "totalTokens": 214202, "cost": 2.6201, "durationMs": 90035, "answer": "(a) The licensed electrician was **Pavlos Stamatopoulos**, master electrician, NY license **#EL-449821**. See [discovery-responses-received.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:138).\n\n(b) The exact invoice annotation was: **\u201c1 GFCI omitted per HO request \u2014 see attached note\u201d**. See [discovery-responses-received.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:162).\n\n(c) The missing companion document was the **\u201cattached note\u201d** referenced in that annotation. The responses say no such note was attached or produced, and the production log only lists the two-page Stamatopoulos invoice at **KCB-000022 \u2013 KCB-000023**. See [document-production-log.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md:52).", "judgeReason": "covers all asked facts", "toolCalls": 6, "trajectory": [ { "step": 1, "inputTokens": 211443, "outputTokens": 2759, "text": "I\u2019ll cross-check the three referenced files directly and pull the exact supporting lines so the answer is tied to the record.\nThe initial pass found the key overlap: the responses identify Pavlos Stamatopoulos and quote the invoice annotation; the production log has the Bates range for that invoice and flags what is missing. I\u2019m reading the surrounding passages now to avoid flattening a disputed point into an undisputed one.\n(a) The licensed electrician was **Pavlos Stamatopoulos**, master electrician, NY license **#EL-449821**. See [discovery-responses-received.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:138).\n\n(b) The exact invoice annotation was: **\u201c1 GFCI omitted per HO request \u2014 see attached note\u201d**. See [discovery-responses-received.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:162).\n\n(c) The missing companion document was the **\u201cattached note\u201d** referenced in that annotation. The responses say no such note was attached or produced, and the production log only lists the two-page Stamatopoulos invoice at **KCB-000022 \u2013 KCB-000023**. See [document-production-log.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md:52).", "toolCalls": [ { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'rg -n \\\"licensed electrician|electrician|license|sink|outlet|invoice|Park kitchen|Park\\\" discovery/discovery-responses-received.md pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md discovery/document-production-log.md'\"}", "outputPreview": "pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md:42:Wendell Park\npleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md:74:1. JURISDICTION AND VENUE. This Court has jurisdiction pursuant to Article 18 of the New York City Civil Court Act (NYCCCA \u00a7\u00a7 1801\u20131814), governing the Small Claims Part. The amount in controversy, $7,500.00, does not exceed the $10,000.00 jurisdictional limit of the Small Claims Part. Venue is prope\u2026", "outputChars": 28056 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'ls -R'\"}", "outputPreview": "client_intake\ncorrespondence\ndiscovery\nmemory\nnotes\npleadings\nprofile.md\nresearch\n\n./client_intake:\ncase-strategy-initial-memo.md\nconflict-check-memo.md\nintake-form-completed.md\nphotos-and-receipts-park-evidence.md\nretainer-agreement.md\n\n./correspondence:\nclient\ncourt\nopposing\n\n./correspondence/client:\nintake-emails-park.md\npre-hearing-prep-park.md\nstatus-updates-park.md\n\n./correspondence/court:\nf\u2026", "outputChars": 1216 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"nl -ba discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '45,58p'\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": " 45\t|---|---|---|---|---|\n 46\t| KCB-000001 \u2013 000012 | Construction contract \u2014 Karras's executed copy, including Addendum A and Addendum B. | Karras Custom Builders office files. | 2025-11-04 | **Cross-check:** matches PARK-000001\u2013000012 page-for-page; no clandestine markings or differences detected on Renee's overlay review (lightbox, 2026-03-13). |\n 47\t| KCB-000013 | **Handwritten note**\u2026", "outputChars": 4867 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"nl -ba discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '100,170p'\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": " 100\t### Bucket 3 \u2014 Subcontractor / Supplier Records\n 101\t\n 102\t**Produced.**\n 103\t\n 104\t- **Crystallo Surfaces invoice** for the quartz countertop slab, showing **batch QS-2025-1182**, the date of fabrication (2025-12-09), the delivery date (2025-12-19), and the manufacturer's standard 1-year limited warranty terms (excluding \"stress fractures attributable to substrate movement\"). *Bate\u2026", "outputChars": 8851 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc \\\"nl -ba pleadings/complaint-filed-2026-02-26.md | sed -n '78,96p'\\\"\"}", "outputPreview": " 78\t3. THE CONTRACT. On November 4, 2025, Plaintiff and Defendant Stefan Karras (on behalf of Karras Custom Builders LLC) executed a written home-improvement contract for a complete kitchen renovation of the subject premises (the \"Contract\"), at a total price of Twenty-Four Thousand Five Hundred Dollars ($24,500.00). The agreed scope included: (a) demolition and removal of existing cabinetry, c\u2026", "outputChars": 7605 }, { "name": "command_execution", "input": "{\"command\": \"/bin/zsh -lc 'smfs grep \\\"Pavlos invoice annotation see attached note GFCI omitted homeowner request\\\" discovery/'\"}", "outputPreview": "# supermemory semantic search \u2014 10 results for \"Pavlos invoice annotation see attached note GFCI omitted homeowner request\"\n# searches by meaning across files in this container. usage:\n# grep \"natural language query\" search all files\n# grep \"query\" path/to/dir/ search within directory\n# output: :-: (chunk text is verbatim from the fi\u2026", "outputChars": 9179 } ] } ] } }