dp_004 q05 (Codex) | Evaluation Runs

Codex

dp_004 q05 30 files multi_hop Codex

Karras claims a $4,500 change order was verbally approved on a specific date in early 2026. Cross-referencing the defense discovery responses (discovery/discovery-responses-received.md), the document-production log (discovery/document-production-log.md), and the case overview (memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md): (a) What specific date does Karras identify as when the verbal change-order approval occurred? (b) What does the defense's own daily-log production reveal about that exact date? (c) How does the case overview characterize Karras's counterclaim on the change order?

Gold answer

(a) On or about 2025-12-18 (per the discovery responses' daily-log gap). (b) There is no daily-log entry for 2025-12-18 — the log is silent on that day. (c) The case overview states the counterclaim seeks $4,500 for the alleged change order and that Karras is not counterclaiming for the $8,500 completion tranche.

Filesystem View raw JSON

Input

531k

Output

Steps

Tools

Latency

2.4m

Cost

$6.59

#1 Ran rg --files agent_memory discovery memory/cases 1,773 chars

Command command_execution

rg --files agent_memory discovery memory/cases

Result 8 lines

rg: discovery: No such file or directory (os error 2)
rg: memory/cases: No such file or directory (os error 2)
agent_memory/discovery/discovery-requests-served.md
agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md
agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md
agent_memory/pleadings/demand-letter-2026-02-19.md
agent_memory/pleadings/answer-2026-03-03.md
agent_memory/pleadings/complaint-file…

Command command_execution

rg -n "4,500|4500|change order|change-order|verbal|verbally|daily log|daily-log" discovery/discovery-responses-received.md discovery/document-production-log.md memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md agent_memory

Result 4 lines

rg: discovery/discovery-responses-received.md: No such file or directory (os error 2)
rg: discovery/document-production-log.md: No such file or directory (os error 2)
rg: memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md: No such file or directory (os error 2)
agent_memory/correspondence/client/status-updates-park.md:33:- Mon 2026-02-16: I draft the demand letter; cite GBL §771 (written-change-order req…

#1 Ran rg -n \"Interrogatory No\\. 2|2026-01-04|Jan|January|12/18|daily-log|daily log|KCB-000|4,500|verbal\" agent_memory/discovery/discovery-respo… 8,323 chars

Command command_execution

rg -n \"Interrogatory No\\. 2|2026-01-04|Jan|January|12/18|daily-log|daily log|KCB-000|4,500|verbal\" agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md

Result 2 lines

36:Enclosed please find Defendants Karras Custom Builders LLC and Stefan Karras's good-faith responses to the document requests and five interrogatories served March 5, 2026. Pursuant to the parties' agreement to proceed informally given the small-claims posture, we are producing **forty-seven (47) documents**, Bates-numbered **KCB-000001 through KCB-000047**, organized by your bucket headings.
53…

Command command_execution

rg -n \"2026-01-04|01-04|Jan|January|daily-log|daily log|KCB-000|Karras's daily|Wendell|4,500|verbal\" agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md

Result 2 lines

28:| PARK-000001 – 000012 | Construction contract dated **2025-11-04** between Wendell Park and Karras Custom Builders LLC, plus signed Addendum A (scope clarification) and Addendum B (countertop selection). | Wendell's home file binder. | 2025-11-04 | Both signatures (Wendell + Stefan) on p. 7. Initials present on every page. Total contract price $24,500 stated p. 3. |
29:| PARK-000013 – 000020 |…

Command command_execution

rg -n "2026-01-04|4,500|change order|verbally|verbal|counterclaim|No writing|on or about" agent_memory/memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md

Result 4 lines

11:- **Matter type:** Small-claims civil action; faulty kitchen renovation. Theories: breach of contract, breach of implied warranty, NYC HIC code-violation; counterclaim for $4,500 alleged change order.
52:- **Total:** **$24,500.**
63:| Add-on (disputed) | **$4,500** | invoiced **2026-01-15** | — | **refused** by Wendell |
65:**Total Wendell paid: $18,000.** Contract balance unpaid: $6,500. Karra…

#1 Ran nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '70,155p' 9,529 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '70,155p'

Result 8 lines

    70	
    71	### Bucket 1 — Contract and Change Orders
    72	
    73	**Produced.** The fully executed written contract dated **2025-11-04**, signed by Wendell Park and Stefan Karras, with the line-item schedule, the payment schedule ($8,000 / $8,000 / $8,500), and the signed scope-of-work attachment.
    74	
    75	  *Bates:* **KCB-000001 to KCB-000012** (12 pages).
    76	
    77	**No written …

#1 Ran nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '44,56p' 4,573 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '44,56p'

Result 3 lines

    44	| Bates Range | Description | Source / Custodian (per Ortega) | Date(s) of Doc | Notes |
    45	|---|---|---|---|---|
    46	| KCB-000001 – 000012 | Construction contract — Karras's executed copy, including Addendum A and Addendum B. | Karras Custom Builders office files. | 2025-11-04 | **Cross-check:** matches PARK-000001–000012 page-for-page; no clandestine markings or differences detecte…

#1 Ran nl -ba agent_memory/memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '58,86p' 3,156 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba agent_memory/memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '58,86p'

Result 6 lines

    58	| Tranche | Amount | Due/paid | Form | Status |
    59	|---|---|---|---|---|
    60	| Deposit | **$8,000** | paid **2025-11-04** | check **#2147** | cleared |
    61	| Mid-project | **$8,000** | paid **2025-12-22** | check **#2168** | cleared |
    62	| Completion | **$8,500** | due on completion | — | **not paid** (incomplete/defective) |
    63	| Add-on (disputed) | **$4,500** | invoiced …

#1 Ran rg -n "2025-12-18|12/18|December 18|Dec(ember)? 18|the date of the alleged verbal" agent_memory 5,009 chars

Command command_execution

rg -n "2025-12-18|12/18|December 18|Dec(ember)? 18|the date of the alleged verbal" agent_memory

Result 2 lines

agent_memory/client_intake/photos-and-receipts-park-evidence.md:44:| Floor (porcelain tile, grout joints, transitions) | 11 | 2025-12-18 → 2026-02-06 | Includes lifted-tile sequence near refrigerator. |
agent_memory/client_intake/intake-form-completed.md:154:- **Change-order invoice 2026-01-15** ($4,500): single page, Karras Custom Builders letterhead. Description reads: *"Upgraded cabinet hardwar…

Command command_execution

rg -n "2026-01-04|01/04|Jan(uary)? 4|January 4|early January|early Jan|on or about" agent_memory

Result 1 lines

agent_memory/notes/client-meeting-notes.md:61:Wendell raised, unprompted, the next-door neighbor at 1610 Argyle Road: **Margot Lévesque**, 47, retired NYC public-school teacher, lives there 8 years. Margot had seen Karras's white F-250 most weekdays December through mid-January and — through the open kitchen window in early January (cracked for paint fumes) — overheard at least two arguments betwe…

Command command_execution

find . -maxdepth 4 -type f | sort | sed 's#"'^./##'"' | rg \"KCB|daily|log|production|responses|overview|case\"

Result 6 lines

agent_memory/client_intake/case-strategy-initial-memo.md
agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md
agent_memory/discovery/document-production-log.md
agent_memory/memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md
agent_memory/research/precedent-cases-memo.md

#1 Ran rg -n "KCB-000025|KCB-000026|KCB-000027|2026-01-04|2026-01-05|January 4|Jan 4|01-04|2025-12-18|12 working days|Notable gaps" . 6,299 chars

Command command_execution

rg -n "KCB-000025|KCB-000026|KCB-000027|2026-01-04|2026-01-05|January 4|Jan 4|01-04|2025-12-18|12 working days|Notable gaps" .

Result 2 lines

./agent_memory/pleadings/answer-2026-03-03.md:51:12. **¶ 12 (change order).** **DENIED** as to the allegation that the $4,500 change order was "oral-only" without authority; **DENIED** that Plaintiff did not approve it. Defendants affirmatively allege Plaintiff verbally approved the change order on 2025-12-18 (see Affirmative Defense 1 and Counterclaim).
./agent_memory/pleadings/answer-2026-03-03.…

#1 Ran date -j -f "%Y-%m-%d" 2026-01-04 "+%A" 7 chars

Command command_execution

date -j -f "%Y-%m-%d" 2026-01-04 "+%A"

Result 2 lines

Sunday

#1 Ran /bin/zsh -lc pwd 93 chars

Command command_execution

/bin/zsh -lc pwd

Result 2 lines

/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004

Answer

The cross-check exposes a date inconsistency. (a) In the defense discovery responses, Karras identifies **December 18, 2025**, around 11 AM-noon, as the alleged oral approval date, not early 2026. [discovery-responses-received.md](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/fs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:144) (b) The defense’s own daily-log production shows **no log entry for December 18, 2025**, specifically flagging it …

Judge: covers all asked facts

SMFS Won View raw JSON

Input

370k

Output

Steps

Tools

Latency

3.0m

Cost

$4.64

Command command_execution

rg -n "4,500|4500|change order|verbal|approved|approval|daily log|daily-log" discovery/discovery-responses-received.md

Result 2 lines

61:1. **Relevance.** To information not bearing on the five defects pled or on the $4,500 counterclaim.
77:**No written change order exists.** The change order at the heart of the counterclaim — **$4,500 for upgraded cabinet hardware and one additional outlet** — was, per Mr. Karras, agreed to **orally** during a 2025-12-18 in-kitchen conversation with Mr. Park (see Interrogatory 2). No paper or e…

Command command_execution

rg -n "4,500|4500|change order|counterclaim|verbal|approved|approval" memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md

Result 4 lines

11:- **Matter type:** Small-claims civil action; faulty kitchen renovation. Theories: breach of contract, breach of implied warranty, NYC HIC code-violation; counterclaim for $4,500 alleged change order.
52:- **Total:** **$24,500.**
63:| Add-on (disputed) | **$4,500** | invoiced **2026-01-15** | — | **refused** by Wendell |
65:**Total Wendell paid: $18,000.** Contract balance unpaid: $6,500. Karra…

Command command_execution

rg -n "4,500|4500|change order|verbal|approved|approval|daily log|daily-log|2026" discovery/document-production-log.md

Result 5 lines

1:# DOCUMENT PRODUCTION LOG — Park v. Karras Custom Builders LLC, Matter OL-2026-0019
3:> Maintained by R. Choudhury. Last updated 2026-03-19 17:00.
13:- **First hearing:** Friday 2026-03-20, 9:30 AM, Part 5 (Hon. Marisol Vega)
17:- **Storage:** Original USB (sealed, drawer A-3); working copy on firm NAS (AES-256, `/legal/2026/0019/`); offsite mirror BackBlaze B2 bucket `ostrowski-legal-2026`.
24:…

#1 Ran nl -ba discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '72,83p;142,153p' 2,766 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '72,83p;142,153p'

Result 6 lines

    72	
    73	**Produced.** The fully executed written contract dated **2025-11-04**, signed by Wendell Park and Stefan Karras, with the line-item schedule, the payment schedule ($8,000 / $8,000 / $8,500), and the signed scope-of-work attachment.
    74	
    75	  *Bates:* **KCB-000001 to KCB-000012** (12 pages).
    76	
    77	**No written change order exists.** The change order at the heart of t…

#1 Ran nl -ba memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '78,87p;136,142p' 1,374 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '78,87p;136,142p'

Result 8 lines

    78	
    79	---
    80	
    81	## 7. Karras's Defense (locked summary)
    82	
    83	- Wendell allegedly approved a **$4,500 mid-project change order verbally** on or about 2026-01-04 for "upgraded cabinet hardware and additional outlet." No writing. No invoice until 2026-01-15.
    84	- Cabinet level "within trade tolerance (1/4"–1/2")."
    85	- Countertop crack is a **Crystallo manufacturer…

#1 Ran nl -ba discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '44,56p' 4,573 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba discovery/document-production-log.md | sed -n '44,56p'

Result 3 lines

    44	| Bates Range | Description | Source / Custodian (per Ortega) | Date(s) of Doc | Notes |
    45	|---|---|---|---|---|
    46	| KCB-000001 – 000012 | Construction contract — Karras's executed copy, including Addendum A and Addendum B. | Karras Custom Builders office files. | 2025-11-04 | **Cross-check:** matches PARK-000001–000012 page-for-page; no clandestine markings or differences detecte…

Command command_execution

rg -n \"2026-01-04|January 4|Jan(?:uary)?\\.? 4|12/18|December 18|2025-12-18|change[- ]order|change order\" .

Result 1 lines

./discovery/document-production-log.md:32:| PARK-000049 – 000060 | Karras's $4,500 change-order invoice (dated 2026-01-15) plus Wendell's annotated objections (12 pages: 1 invoice + 11 annotation pages). Annotations in Wendell's hand, blue ballpoint, dated 2026-01-17. | Wendell's home file. | 2026-01-15 (invoice); 2026-01-17 (annotations) | Wendell's annotation on line item 3 — "I never approved h…

#1 Ran smfs grep "Karras verbal change order approval date early 2026 daily log gap" 6,428 chars

Command command_execution

smfs grep "Karras verbal change order approval date early 2026 daily log gap"

Result 3 lines

# supermemory semantic search — 10 results for "Karras verbal change order approval date early 2026 daily log gap"/memory/hearing-outcome.md:Karras has 30 days until 2026-06-05 to file an appeal for the Park v. Karras case.

/memory/hearing-outcome.md:Carmen Ostrowski won the Park v. Karras hearing: Wendell Park was awarded $7,500 compensatory damages and $20 filing fees, while Karras's $4,500 cou…

#1 Ran find . -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort | sed -n '1,220p' 1,373 chars

Command command_execution

find . -maxdepth 3 -type f | sort | sed -n '1,220p'

Result 9 lines

./client_intake/case-strategy-initial-memo.md
./client_intake/conflict-check-memo.md
./client_intake/intake-form-completed.md
./client_intake/photos-and-receipts-park-evidence.md
./client_intake/retainer-agreement.md
./correspondence/client/intake-emails-park.md
./correspondence/client/pre-hearing-prep-park.md
./correspondence/client/status-updates-park.md
./correspondence/court/filing-receipt-and…

Command command_execution

rg -n \"2026-01-04|Jan(?:uary)?\\.? 4|early January|on or about 2026-01-04|01-04|1/4\" .

Result 1 lines

./pleadings/settlement-offer-exchange.md:48:- The cabinet alignment your client characterizes as "off-level" falls within trade tolerance — industry guidance (NKBA installation standards) recognizes 1/4" to 1/2" variance over a continuous run as acceptable, particularly in pre-war masonry where wall plumb is itself out of true. We respectfully maintain the **trade-tolerance position on cabinet lev…

#1 Ran nl -ba discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '1,240p' 20,963 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba discovery/discovery-responses-received.md | sed -n '1,240p'

Result 7 lines

     1	# DEFENDANT'S RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFF'S INFORMAL DISCOVERY — Park v. Karras Custom Builders LLC, Index SC-002847-26/KI
     2	
     3	```
     4	[REC'D 2026-03-12 15:08 RC]                                       [Bates stamp lower-right]
     5	```
     6	
     7	*Renee snapped a phone photo of the Bates stamp on the first page for the production log; the photo is filed under `/discovery/inta…

#1 Ran nl -ba memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '1,170p' 15,591 chars

Command command_execution

nl -ba memory/cases/park-v-karras-case-overview.md | sed -n '1,170p'

Result 10 lines

     1	# CASE OVERVIEW — Park v. Karras Custom Builders LLC, Index SC-002847-26/KI. Maintained for memory retrieval. Last updated 2026-03-19 17:30.
     2	
     3	> Confidential — Attorney Work Product. Canonical case-management memory for the Park matter; referenced by every other dp_004 file.
     4	
     5	---
     6	
     7	## 1. Identity
     8	
     9	- **Matter ID:** OL-2026-0019.
    10	- …

Answer

(a) Karras identifies **December 18, 2025**, about **11:00 AM to 12:00 PM**, as the alleged verbal approval date. The defense responses also say the later invoice email referred to “discussion 12/18.” See [discovery responses](/Users/prasanna/Documents/supermemoryai/supermemoryfs/.scratch/eval/eval/workspace/smfs/dp_004/agent_memory/discovery/discovery-responses-received.md:144). (b) The defense’s own production log says Karras’s daily logs have **no entry for 2025-12-18**, expressly flagging t…

Judge: covers all asked facts